Derby Pie Brownies
The best way to celebrate the Kentucky Derby is with a mint julep in one hand and Derby Pie Brownies in the other. Chocolate Brownies covered in bourbon, toasted pecans, and chocolate chips!
Derby Pie Brownies
Grab your hat, your Mint Julep, and these Derby Pie Brownies. The Kentucky Derby is coming up soon and you need to get ready to celebrate!
At the Kentucky Derby, everyone is drinking bourbon, eating Derby Pie, and cheering on their favorite horse! I had the privilege to go to the Kentucky Derby in 2013 and it was such an amazing experience.
It was such a great time walking around looking at hats, celebrity stalking when I saw one come in, drinking Oaks Lilies (the drink of the Oaks on Friday), and feeling the horses shake the ground when they raced by.
I am still not a huge fan of bourbon in my drinks, but I do love it in my food.
The best example of this is the Derby Pie. That classic combination of toasted pecans, chocolate chips, and bourbon filling a flaky pie crust. How about we take these classic flavors and add them to even more chocolate!!!
The Kentucky Derby also makes me think of bourbon balls. I stick to the Oaks Lilies vodka drinks but bourbon reigns king and so do these Bourbon Balls that my husband’s grandma used to make.
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Read my disclosure policy.
Ingredients Needed
- semi-sweet chocolate
- melted butter
- sugar
- eggs
- vanilla
- flour
- brown sugar
- dark corn syrup
- bourbon
- toasted pecans
For more insider tips, tricks, and a behind the scenes look, follow me on Pinterest, Facebook, Instagram, & X.
How to make Derby Pie Brownies
First: Make the Brownie Layer Preheat the oven to 350F. Melt the butter in a glass bowl in the microwave. Add chocolate and stir until melted.
Second: Add the sugar, vanilla, and eggs. Stir to combine. Add the flour and stir until mixed through.
Third: Pour into a 9×13 pan lined with non-stick foil or parchment paper. Bake at 350F for 25 minutes. Remove from oven.
Fourth: Make the Derby Pie Layer Mix brown sugar, corn syrup, butter, eggs, and bourbon until combined. Add the toasted pecans and chocolate chips.
Fifth: Pour on top of the brownie layer. Bake at 350F for 35 minutes until center is set. Remove from oven and cool completely.
For the full recipe and detailed instructions, please refer to the recipe card at the bottom of the post.
Kentucky Derby Foods
Looking to host a Kentucky Derby Party? Here is a list of Kentucky Derby Food and some cute decorations!
Among them are my Derby Pie Bites, Derby Pie Cheese Ball, and Derby Pie Dip!
If you love this recipe as much as I do, please leave us a five-star review in the comment section below. Thanks!
Whip up a batch of these Derby Pie Brownies, grab your big outrageous hat, and head on over to your Kentucky Derby party! Don’t forget your Mint Julep too!
Derby Pie Brownies
Ingredients
For the Brownie Layer
- 4 ounces semi-sweet chocolate
- 3/4 cup melted butter
- 2 cups sugar
- 3 eggs
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 1 cup flour
For the Derby Pie Layer
- 1 cup brown sugar firmly packed
- 1 cup dark corn syrup
- 1/2 cup melted butter
- 4 large eggs
- 3 tablespoons bourbon
- 1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
- 2 cups chopped toasted pecans
Instructions
Make the Brownie Layer
- Preheat the oven to 350F.
Make the brownie layer:
- Melt the butter in a glass bowl in the microwave.
- Add chocolate and stir until melted.
- Add the sugar, vanilla, and eggs.
- Stir to combine.
- Add the flour and stir until mixed through.
- Pour into a 9×13 pan lined with non-stick foil or parchment paper.
- Bake at 350F for 25 minutes.
- Remove from oven.
Make the Derby Pie Layer
- Mix brown sugar, corn syrup, butter, eggs, and bourbon until combined.
- Add the toasted pecans and chocolate chips.
- Pour on top of the brownie layer.
- Bake at 350F for 35 minutes until center is set.
- Remove from oven and cool completely.
- Slice and enjoy!
Notes
Nutrition
More Brownie Ideas
©TakeTwoTapas.com. Content and photographs are copyright protected. Sharing of this recipe is both encouraged and appreciated. Copying and/or pasting full recipes to any social media is strictly prohibited.
I realized too late that this was a mostly untried recipe—most comments are how good it LOOKS or SOUNDS! There’s no explanation as to how “done” the brownie layer should be before pouring the Derby Pie layer on top. If you follow directions it’s probably going to do what mine did and just ooze into one ooey -gooey layer. I cooked at least 15 minutes longer than directed AFTER adding top layer, and still it wasn’t really done. After it cooled for two hours, I was able to take out of pan, cut into long, wide strips and bake for 20 MORE minutes.
Then I served in bowls with vanilla ice cream on top. Delish? Yes! As presented? Nope!
Thank you! I am going to try this using a box of gluten-free brownie mix as the brownie layer. I have someone with celiac disease, but loves brownies!
I have made these with a gluten free mix and they turn out great!
I want to make these for a Derby party this weekend! Can I make them ahead of time and freeze them so that they’re fresh?
You sure can~
Do you have to make any adjustments for high altitude?
I haven’t baked these at high altitude, I live below sea level but as a rule of thumb when baking brownies over 5000ft, decrease sugar by 1 tablespoons per cup and add 1 to 2 tablespoons of liquid, such as water, to the brownie layer. I hope this helps. If they turn out please let me know so I can add this information to my post:)
Great recipe!
I made these for a derby party and they were so good! They were fudgy and delicious! People loved them so much they took the rest home!
I am so glad that you and your guests liked them! They are my favorite too!
I made these for a derby party and they were so good! They were fudgy and delicious! People loved them so much they took the rest home!
Did anyone have any problem with the length of baking time? Mine stayed so gooey jiggly so I baked it for almost another 20 minutes and it stayed gooey in the middle and too hard to chew all around the outside. It had good flavor but I had to throw them away because they just weren’t right.
Kim, I am so sorry that you had problems with the recipe and had to throw them away. That’s no good! I haven’t had anyone else say they have had problems but I can offer some suggestions. Did the brownie layer cook and just not the pie layer? First, check the temperature on your oven. I have had problems in the past with mine going out of whack and being off from the desired temp and having to adjust my knob. Next, I would try lowering the cooking temperature to 325F so they can cook longer without drying out. Last, I would try cooking the brownie layer for about 5 minutes less before adding the pie layer. I hope this helps. Please get back to me and let me know if they work. If not, I can try some other things. Thank you for being a reader! You will probably like my derby pie bites:)
@Kim Blackwell, I had the same problem! Reading your comment made me feel better!
Hello!
Would the recipe change if I used a box mix for the brownies? Do I cook the brownies completely before I put them back in the oven with the topping? Should I use one or two boxed mixes?
Thanks!
You can definitely use a box mix for the brownie layer. I love the Duncan Hines dark chocolate fudge family size brand when I sub a box mix. Just make sure that you use a family size or you will have to use 2 boxes that are the 8×8 size. I would still cook them for the 25 minutes because you still need to cook them for another 35 minutes and if you cook them all the way they will be way too dry. Thanks for reading!!
Made these last night for a derby party. I am not much of a baker and my kitchen is mostly packed up for a remodeling starting next week, so I used a boxed mix for the brownies. I also was in a rush so I probably should have let them cool more before the party. And I didn’t grease the pan enough so they stuck a bit.
Despite all of this, they turned out amazing! They were still warm and gooey. The bourbon has just enough of a hint that the adults could taste it but the kids weren’t put off by it. My daughter has a peanut allergy so is sometimes suspicious of other nuts but she even came back for seconds. My husband and the others at the party are huge bourbon fans and they all raved about this dessert. I am definitely saving this recipe for the future.
I am so glad that you liked them and that they were a hit at your Derby Party! I will admit that I have used boxed mix on occasion too because we are all strapped for time! Thank you so much for being a reader and I look forward to bringing you more Derby party recipes in the future:)
Made these last night for a derby party. I am not much of a baker and my kitchen is mostly packed up for a remodeling starting next week, so I used a boxed mix for the brownies. I also was in a rush so I probably should have let them cool more before the party. And I didn’t grease the pan enough so they stuck a bit.
Despite all of this, they turned out amazing! They were still warm and gooey. The bourbon has just enough of a hint that the adults could taste it but the kids weren’t put off by it. My daughter has a peanut allergy so is sometimes suspicious of other nuts but she even came back for seconds. My husband and the others at the party are huge bourbon fans and they all raved about this dessert. I am definitely saving this recipe for the future.
So much YUM in such a small brownie! Thank you for linking up to last weeks Creative K Kids’ Tasty Tuesday. Don’t forget to link up this week, if you haven’t already!
These looks so good! Sorry it took so long to visit – I’ve been off on vacation! Thanks for sharing on the What’s for Dinner link up!
One of these days I’m finally going to make it to a horse race…it’s on my bucket list. Until then, I’ll settle for a few of these brownies! Happy Fiesta Friday!
My favorite sporting event! What a great combination of two winning desserts. I’m adding this to “baking” list.
Thanks Noel!!
I love your hat guess you had so much fun. Never heard about derbie pie. I like brown sugar flavour this looks like something my family will enjoy
The traditional derby pie is like a pecan pie but with chocolate and a little flour in it. Almost like a cookie pie. I love it with the brownies!
Those are some phenomenal looking brownies! And since I love pecans, these are right up my alley!
Gotta have that texture!
It certainly looks and sounds great. Lots of the girls at my school would go to the Kentucky Derby — they always came back raving about the experience. Now your pie looks like it would be an experience in itself.
It truly is! I can’t get enough of them this time of year!
How lovely this is, looks gooey and so yummy. Your outfit and that hat are so pretty you look so pretty and so elegant. I love derby events.
Thank you so much! Checking out everyone else’s hats and dresses was almost as fun as watching the horses!
There’s a derby themed event that my friend is having in a few weeks. These brownies would be just perfect.
I hope they enjoy them! They are always a hit at my house!
These look delicious. Such a fun spin on a brownie. I am sure the pretzels give the perfect amount of crunch.
I love my brownies especially with some texture!
These look so good. I love the topping. Pecans go so well with brownies..! Yum. Can’t wait to try these.
Thanks! They do!
These look Heavenly and I love your hat! W’re throwing a big Derby party this year and I think I’ll just have to make these!
Thanks so much! I had such a great time and was so mad that it rained on my hat!
Oh, that topping looks like pure heaven and both of you looked stunning on the Derby!
Thank you Petra!!
Looks so yummy. Thanks for sharing at the Inspiration Spotlight party. Pinned & shared. See you again soon.
Thank you for a great party!
These really lol fabulous!!
Thank you Erin!
These really lol fabulous!!
These really lol fabulous!!
Looking forward to trying these! Pinning. Visiting from Create It Thursday.
Thanks for a great party!
I’ve been hearing a lot about Derby Pie and these bars look pretty darned special! I might have to have hat to eat them! Thanks for linking up with us at Throwback Thursday!
Mollie
No hat needed. Just an appetite:) Thanks for a great party!
These brownies look AMAZING !!
So rich looking
YUMMY !
Thanks Winnie!
These brownies look AMAZING !!
So rich looking
YUMMY !
These brownies look AMAZING !!
So rich looking
YUMMY !
I’m so jealous that you actually got to go to the Kentucky Derby! It’s definitely on my list of things to do someday! I love the brownie recipe too. It looks delicious…thanks so much for sharing it with us at Share The Wealth Sunday! xoxo
I am hoping to go to the Masters next! It was an adventure!
Derby or not, I want these brownies ASAP! They look so absolutely scrumptious!
Thank you Kathryn~
Derby or not, I want these brownies ASAP! They look so absolutely scrumptious!
Derby or not, I want these brownies ASAP! They look so absolutely scrumptious!
I’ve never heard of Derby pies until now, and I must say: heart eyes all over this delicious treat. Definitely pinning and sharing for later. Thanks so much for joining us this week on #shinebloghop. This recipe is great and the results looks so gorgeous…almost too good to eat (ALMOST)
Thank you for a great party!
Wow, these look so decadent and indulgent! Will have to make these for a potluck at some point, as they definitely will need to be shared. Thanks for the inspiration. Found you at Show and Tell party.
Thank you for checking me out! Love that party!
They look great. What a good brownie idea, thanks for sharing
Thanks Keith!
These sound like really flavorful, sophisticated brownies! Perfect for adults (and hiding them from the kids!)
Inhaling before the kids see them!
you had me at brownie – you can top a brownie with almost anything (well…) and I’d love it! these sound perfect for Derby or ANY day!
Thanks Kristina!
Ha! Ha! I am with you–bourbon in food is so much better than bourbon in drinks! Love these brownies!
Let’s hear it for eating our cocktails!
Pecans are wonderful! Amazing recipe!
Thanks Florian
You look lovely with that hat Jennifer! 🙂 and your brownie recipe is a keeper.. bookmarked it
Thanks Citra! I loved that hat too. I felt so regal wearing it.
Going to the Derby looks like so much fun. One day I would love to do it. Turing Derby pie into brownies is another great idea. What a fun way to change it up.
Thanks Christie:)